Skip to main content

CodiFlow Implementation Plan v2.0

Document Type: Implementation Plan with CODITECT v2 Tasklist Generated: December 22, 2025 MoE Analysis: 5 Experts + 2 Judges (Architecture: 36/40, Quality: 7/40 → 40/40 after revisions) Status: APPROVED WITH REVISIONS INCORPORATED

Executive Summary​

CodiFlow is a Rust-based clean-room implementation of a git-backed workflow engine for AI agents, designed to replace/complement Beads with superior AI intelligence capabilities.

MoE Verdict: HYBRID STRATEGY​

PhaseTimelineDeliverable
Phase 1Dec 23-29Deploy Beads for Pilot Launch (Dec 24)
Phase 2Jan-FebBuild CodiFlow AI Intelligence Layer
Phase 3Mar 11CodiFlow Beta at Public Launch
Phase 4Month 6Market-driven decision point

Key Metrics​

MetricBeadsCodiFlowWinner
Weighted Score5.03/108.13/10CodiFlow (+61.7%)
AI Intelligence1.0/108.3/10CodiFlow
Production Ready7.5/105.5/10Beads (until validated)

Architecture Overview​

5-Layer Architecture​

┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                     Layer 5: Sync Daemon                         │
│  Event-driven (<500ms latency) | Git hooks | GCP backup          │
├──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│                        Layer 4: CLI                              │
│  Cobra-style commands | --json output | Shell completions        │
├──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│                        Layer 3: RPC                              │
│  Unix domain sockets | Windows named pipes | MCP protocol        │
├──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│                   Layer 2: Business Logic                        │
│  Task CRUD | Dependency graph | Agent routing | Semantic search  │
├──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│                      Layer 1: Storage                            │
│  SQLite + FTS5 | Blake3 IDs | Merkle tree sync | context.db      │
└──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Technology Choices​

ComponentTechnologyRationale
LanguageRust 2021Memory safety, zero-cost abstractions, 10MB binary
DatabaseSQLite + FTS5Integration with context.db, semantic search
ID GenerationBlake310x faster than SHA-256, collision-resistant
SyncMerkle treesO(log n) diff detection, git-friendly JSONL
RPCUnix sockets<500ms latency vs 5s polling
AIEmbeddings + LLMSemantic search, duplicate detection, agent routing

Judge Panel Synthesis​

Architecture Judge: 36/40 (APPROVED WITH MINOR REVISIONS)​

Strengths:

  • Exceptional 5-layer architecture
  • Proper Rust trait-based extensibility
  • Event-driven daemon design
  • Integration with existing context.db

Required Fixes (Incorporated):

  1. Split 3 oversized tasks (>16h) into sub-tasks
  2. Add session tracking fields to Task model
  3. Specify SQLite WAL configuration
  4. Document LLM provider options
  5. Add daemon dependency graph
  6. Fix agent assignment for shell completions

Quality Judge: 7/40 → 40/40 (After Revisions)​

Critical Issues Fixed:

  1. Test coverage: 8% → 30.4% (added 28 test tasks)
  2. TDD workflow: Tests scheduled BEFORE implementation
  3. Quality gates: Defined for all 4 phases
  4. CI/CD: 8 infrastructure tasks added
  5. Security testing: OWASP Top 10 coverage
  6. Performance testing: Load benchmarks added

CODITECT v2 Tasklist Format​

- [ ] **TASK-ID** | PRIORITY | PHASE | Est: Xh | Agent: AGENT-NAME
  - **Task:** Description of what needs to be done
  - **Acceptance:** Measurable success criteria
  - **Deps:** [Dependencies]
  - **Blocks:** [What this blocks]

Phase 0: TDD Foundation (NEW - Per Quality Judge)​

Goal: Establish test infrastructure BEFORE implementation Effort: 30h | Tasks: 10 | Agent: testing-specialist

TDD Test Scaffolding​

  • CF-T01 | P0 | Phase 0 | Est: 2h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Write failing unit tests for file watcher system
    • Acceptance: Test suite skeleton exists, all tests fail (RED state)
    • Deps: None
    • Blocks: [CF-CORE-001]

  • CF-T02 | P0 | Phase 0 | Est: 2h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Write failing unit tests for git integration layer
    • Acceptance: Git operation tests fail, mock framework configured
    • Deps: None
    • Blocks: [CF-SYNC-001]

  • CF-T03 | P0 | Phase 0 | Est: 2h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Write failing unit tests for session management
    • Acceptance: Session lifecycle tests fail, anti-forgetting fields tested
    • Deps: None
    • Blocks: [CF-CORE-001]

  • CF-T04 | P0 | Phase 0 | Est: 3h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Write failing unit tests for component discovery
    • Acceptance: Component registry tests fail, 130+ agent discovery tested
    • Deps: None
    • Blocks: [CF-CORE-005, CF-CORE-006, CF-CORE-007]

  • CF-T05 | P0 | Phase 0 | Est: 3h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Write failing unit tests for API client (Claude/LLM)
    • Acceptance: API client tests fail, mock LLM responses configured
    • Deps: None
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-001, CF-AI-002]

  • CF-T06 | P0 | Phase 0 | Est: 3h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Write failing unit tests for command system
    • Acceptance: Command parsing tests fail, 141 commands covered
    • Deps: None
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-001, CF-CLI-002]

  • CF-T07 | P0 | Phase 0 | Est: 2h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Write failing unit tests for tool handler
    • Acceptance: Tool invocation tests fail, error handling tested
    • Deps: None
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-003a]

  • CF-T08 | P0 | Phase 0 | Est: 3h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Write failing unit tests for skill system
    • Acceptance: Skill execution tests fail, dependency resolution tested
    • Deps: None
    • Blocks: [CF-CORE-008]

  • CF-T09 | P0 | Phase 0 | Est: 3h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Write failing unit tests for agent system
    • Acceptance: Agent lifecycle tests fail, 130+ agent metadata validated
    • Deps: None
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-004]

  • CF-T10 | P0 | Phase 0 | Est: 4h | Agent: database-architect

    • Task: SQLite/FTS5 test environment setup with context.db integration
    • Acceptance: Test database configured, FTS5 indexes created, WAL mode enabled
    • Deps: None
    • Blocks: [CF-STORAGE-001]

Phase 1: Core Infrastructure​

Goal: Establish foundational Rust project with storage layer Effort: 48h | Tasks: 12 | Agents: rust-expert-developer, database-architect

Project Setup​

  • CF-CORE-001 | P0 | Phase 1 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Initialize Rust workspace with Cargo.toml and crate structure
    • Acceptance: cargo build succeeds, workspace has crates: codiflow-core, codiflow-cli, codiflow-daemon
    • Deps: [CF-T01, CF-T03] (TDD)
    • Blocks: [CF-CORE-002, CF-STORAGE-001]

  • CF-CORE-002 | P0 | Phase 1 | Est: 3h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Define core Task model with anti-forgetting fields
    • Acceptance: Task struct includes: id (Blake3), title, description, status, priority, created_by_session, token_budget_at_create, timestamps
    • Deps: [CF-CORE-001]
    • Blocks: [CF-STORAGE-002]

Storage Layer​

  • CF-STORAGE-001 | P0 | Phase 1 | Est: 6h | Agent: database-architect

    • Task: SQLite storage implementation with FTS5 full-text search
    • Acceptance: CRUD operations work, FTS5 search returns results in <100ms
    • Deps: [CF-T10, CF-CORE-001]
    • Blocks: [CF-STORAGE-002, CF-AI-003a]

  • CF-STORAGE-002 | P0 | Phase 1 | Est: 4h | Agent: database-architect

    • Task: Task CRUD operations with Blake3 ID generation
    • Acceptance: Create/Read/Update/Delete with unique IDs, collision test passes
    • Deps: [CF-STORAGE-001, CF-CORE-002]
    • Blocks: [CF-STORAGE-003]

  • CF-STORAGE-003 | P0 | Phase 1 | Est: 4h | Agent: database-architect

    • Task: SQLite configuration with WAL mode and optimal PRAGMAs
    • Acceptance: PRAGMA journal_mode=WAL; PRAGMA synchronous=NORMAL; PRAGMA cache_size=-64000;
    • Deps: [CF-STORAGE-002]
    • Blocks: [CF-SYNC-001]

  • CF-STORAGE-004 | P0 | Phase 1 | Est: 4h | Agent: database-architect

    • Task: Context.db integration for unified storage
    • Acceptance: CodiFlow tables coexist with context.db, shared connection pool
    • Deps: [CF-STORAGE-003]
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-003b]

Business Logic​

  • CF-CORE-003 | P0 | Phase 1 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Dependency graph implementation with topological sort
    • Acceptance: Dependency resolution works, cycle detection prevents invalid graphs
    • Deps: [CF-STORAGE-002]
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-003]

  • CF-CORE-004 | P0 | Phase 1 | Est: 3h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Priority queue for task ordering
    • Acceptance: Tasks ordered by priority + dependencies, O(log n) insertion
    • Deps: [CF-CORE-003]
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-004]

  • CF-CORE-005 | P1 | Phase 1 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Component registry for 130+ agents, 141 commands, 186 skills
    • Acceptance: Registry loads from config/, O(1) lookup by name
    • Deps: [CF-T04, CF-CORE-001]
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-004]

  • CF-CORE-006 | P1 | Phase 1 | Est: 3h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Label/tag system with hierarchical namespaces
    • Acceptance: Labels support domain:value format, efficient filtering
    • Deps: [CF-STORAGE-002]
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-005]

  • CF-CORE-007 | P1 | Phase 1 | Est: 3h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Comment/annotation system with threading
    • Acceptance: Comments support parent_id for threading, markdown rendering
    • Deps: [CF-STORAGE-002]
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-006]

  • CF-CORE-008 | P1 | Phase 1 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Skill execution engine with dependency resolution
    • Acceptance: Skills load from skills/*/SKILL.md, dependency order respected
    • Deps: [CF-T08, CF-CORE-005]
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-005]

Phase 2: CLI Implementation​

Goal: Complete command-line interface with all core commands Effort: 36h | Tasks: 9 | Agent: rust-expert-developer

Core Commands​

  • CF-CLI-001 | P0 | Phase 2 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: cf create command with priority, labels, dependencies
    • Acceptance: cf create "Task title" -p 1 -l urgent --deps CF-001 works
    • Deps: [CF-T06, CF-STORAGE-002]
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-002]

  • CF-CLI-002 | P0 | Phase 2 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: cf list command with filtering and --json output
    • Acceptance: cf list --status open --priority 0-1 --json returns valid JSON
    • Deps: [CF-CLI-001]
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-003]

  • CF-CLI-003 | P0 | Phase 2 | Est: 3h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: cf update command for status, priority, labels
    • Acceptance: cf update CF-001 --status in_progress updates correctly
    • Deps: [CF-CLI-002]
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-004]

  • CF-CLI-004 | P0 | Phase 2 | Est: 3h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: cf close command with reason and validation
    • Acceptance: cf close CF-001 --reason "Done" closes task, validates dependencies
    • Deps: [CF-CLI-003]
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-005]

  • CF-CLI-005 | P1 | Phase 2 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: cf search command with FTS5 + semantic search
    • Acceptance: cf search "authentication bug" returns relevant tasks
    • Deps: [CF-STORAGE-001, CF-CLI-002]
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-003a]

  • CF-CLI-006 | P1 | Phase 2 | Est: 3h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: cf show command with full task details
    • Acceptance: cf show CF-001 displays all fields, dependencies, comments
    • Deps: [CF-CLI-002]
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-007]

  • CF-CLI-007 | P1 | Phase 2 | Est: 3h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: cf dep command for dependency management
    • Acceptance: cf dep add CF-002 CF-001 creates dependency, cycle detection works
    • Deps: [CF-CORE-003, CF-CLI-001]
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-008]

  • CF-CLI-008 | P1 | Phase 2 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: cf ready command to show unblocked tasks
    • Acceptance: cf ready --agent rust-expert-developer shows available work
    • Deps: [CF-CORE-003, CF-CORE-004]
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-004]

  • CF-CLI-009 | P2 | Phase 2 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: cf stats command with progress metrics
    • Acceptance: Shows completion %, priority breakdown, agent utilization
    • Deps: [CF-CLI-002]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-001]

Phase 3: AI Intelligence Layer​

Goal: Semantic search, duplicate detection, agent routing Effort: 40h | Tasks: 10 | Agents: ai-specialist, rust-expert-developer

Embedding Generation​

  • CF-AI-001 | P0 | Phase 3 | Est: 6h | Agent: ai-specialist

    • Task: Embedding provider abstraction with local + cloud options
    • Acceptance: Interface supports: llama.cpp (local), Anthropic API (cloud), OpenAI (fallback)
    • Deps: [CF-T05]
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-002]

  • CF-AI-002 | P0 | Phase 3 | Est: 4h | Agent: ai-specialist

    • Task: Task embedding generation and caching
    • Acceptance: Embeddings generated on task create, cached in SQLite, invalidated on update
    • Deps: [CF-AI-001, CF-STORAGE-001]
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-003a]

Semantic Search (Split per Architecture Judge)​

  • CF-AI-003a | P0 | Phase 3 | Est: 8h | Agent: ai-specialist

    • Task: Embedding-based similarity search with FTS5 fallback
    • Acceptance: Cosine similarity search works, falls back to FTS5 if embeddings unavailable
    • Deps: [CF-T07, CF-AI-002, CF-STORAGE-001]
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-003b]

  • CF-AI-003b | P0 | Phase 3 | Est: 6h | Agent: ai-specialist

    • Task: Search result ranking and relevance scoring
    • Acceptance: Results ranked by: semantic similarity (40%), FTS5 score (30%), recency (20%), priority (10%)
    • Deps: [CF-AI-003a, CF-STORAGE-004]
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-005]

Duplicate Detection​

  • CF-AI-004 | P1 | Phase 3 | Est: 6h | Agent: ai-specialist

    • Task: Semantic duplicate detection with merge suggestions
    • Acceptance: cf duplicates finds similar tasks (>0.85 similarity), suggests merges
    • Deps: [CF-T09, CF-AI-003a, CF-CORE-005]
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-005]

  • CF-AI-005 | P1 | Phase 3 | Est: 4h | Agent: ai-specialist

    • Task: Auto-merge workflow for confirmed duplicates
    • Acceptance: cf duplicates --auto-merge merges with dependency preservation
    • Deps: [CF-AI-004, CF-CORE-008]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-002]

Agent Routing​

  • CF-AI-006 | P1 | Phase 3 | Est: 6h | Agent: ai-specialist

    • Task: Task-to-agent routing based on 130+ agent capabilities
    • Acceptance: cf suggest-agent CF-001 returns top-3 agents with confidence scores
    • Deps: [CF-AI-002, CF-CORE-005]
    • Blocks: [CF-AI-007]

  • CF-AI-007 | P2 | Phase 3 | Est: 4h | Agent: ai-specialist

    • Task: Agent workload balancing and utilization tracking
    • Acceptance: Routing considers agent current load, prevents overallocation
    • Deps: [CF-AI-006]
    • Blocks: [CF-CLI-008]

Phase 4: Sync Engine​

Goal: Git-backed JSONL sync with Merkle tree verification Effort: 36h | Tasks: 8 | Agents: rust-expert-developer, devops-engineer

JSONL Export/Import​

  • CF-SYNC-001 | P0 | Phase 4 | Est: 6h | Agent: rust-expert-developer
    • Task: JSONL export with atomic writes and debouncing
    • Acceptance: Changes export within 5s, atomic file writes, no corruption on crash
    • Deps: [CF-T02, CF-STORAGE-003]
    • Blocks: [CF-SYNC-002a]

Merkle Tree (Split per Architecture Judge)​

  • CF-SYNC-002a | P0 | Phase 4 | Est: 8h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Merkle tree implementation for change detection
    • Acceptance: Tree built from task hashes, O(log n) diff detection
    • Deps: [CF-SYNC-001]
    • Blocks: [CF-SYNC-002b]

  • CF-SYNC-002b | P0 | Phase 4 | Est: 8h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Merkle tree sync integration with conflict resolution
    • Acceptance: Sync detects conflicts, presents resolution UI, preserves all data
    • Deps: [CF-SYNC-002a]
    • Blocks: [CF-SYNC-003]

  • CF-SYNC-003 | P0 | Phase 4 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Git hook integration for auto-sync
    • Acceptance: post-commit, post-merge, pre-push hooks installed via cf hooks install
    • Deps: [CF-SYNC-002b]
    • Blocks: [CF-DAEMON-001]

  • CF-SYNC-004 | P1 | Phase 4 | Est: 4h | Agent: devops-engineer

    • Task: GCP backup integration with context.db
    • Acceptance: cf backup uploads to gs://coditect-context-backups, 90-day retention
    • Deps: [CF-SYNC-001, CF-STORAGE-004]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-003]

Phase 5: Daemon Architecture​

Goal: Event-driven background daemon with RPC Effort: 32h | Tasks: 7 | Agents: rust-expert-developer, devops-engineer

Daemon Dependency Graph (per Architecture Judge)​

CF-DAEMON-001 (Core daemon)
    ↓
CF-DAEMON-002 (inotify/fsevents)
    ↓
CF-DAEMON-003 (RPC server)
    ↓
CF-DAEMON-004 (Version checking) ← CF-DAEMON-005 (Health monitoring)

  • CF-DAEMON-001 | P0 | Phase 5 | Est: 6h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Core daemon process with tokio async runtime
    • Acceptance: Daemon starts, handles SIGTERM gracefully, writes PID file
    • Deps: [CF-SYNC-003]
    • Blocks: [CF-DAEMON-002, CF-DAEMON-003]

  • CF-DAEMON-002 | P0 | Phase 5 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: File system watcher with inotify (Linux) / FSEvents (macOS)
    • Acceptance: Detects .codiflow/ changes within 100ms, debounces rapid changes
    • Deps: [CF-DAEMON-001]
    • Blocks: [CF-DAEMON-004]

  • CF-DAEMON-003 | P0 | Phase 5 | Est: 6h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Unix socket RPC server with JSON protocol
    • Acceptance: CLI connects via .codiflow/cf.sock, commands execute in <50ms
    • Deps: [CF-DAEMON-001]
    • Blocks: [CF-DAEMON-004]

  • CF-DAEMON-004 | P0 | Phase 5 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Version mismatch detection and auto-restart
    • Acceptance: Daemon detects version change, warns user, offers restart
    • Deps: [CF-DAEMON-002, CF-DAEMON-003]
    • Blocks: [CF-DAEMON-005]

  • CF-DAEMON-005 | P1 | Phase 5 | Est: 4h | Agent: devops-engineer

    • Task: Health monitoring with Prometheus metrics
    • Acceptance: /metrics endpoint exposes: sync_latency, command_latency, error_count
    • Deps: [CF-DAEMON-004]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-004]

  • CF-DAEMON-006 | P1 | Phase 5 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: Windows named pipe support for cross-platform
    • Acceptance: Same RPC protocol works on Windows via named pipes
    • Deps: [CF-DAEMON-003]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-004]

  • CF-DAEMON-007 | P2 | Phase 5 | Est: 4h | Agent: rust-expert-developer

    • Task: cf daemons command for daemon management
    • Acceptance: cf daemons list, cf daemons health, cf daemons killall work
    • Deps: [CF-DAEMON-005]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-005]

Phase 6: Integration Tests (Split per Architecture Judge)​

Goal: Comprehensive integration and E2E test coverage Effort: 40h | Tasks: 8 | Agent: testing-specialist

Integration Tests​

  • CF-TEST-005a | P0 | Phase 6 | Est: 8h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Storage layer integration tests with real SQLite
    • Acceptance: CRUD, FTS5, transactions tested with real database, not mocks
    • Deps: [CF-STORAGE-004]
    • Blocks: [CF-TEST-005b]

  • CF-TEST-005b | P0 | Phase 6 | Est: 10h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: RPC layer integration tests with daemon
    • Acceptance: CLI→RPC→Storage round-trip tested, concurrent access tested
    • Deps: [CF-TEST-005a, CF-DAEMON-003]
    • Blocks: [CF-T20]

  • CF-T20 | P0 | Phase 6 | Est: 3h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Integration: File watcher → Command system
    • Acceptance: File changes trigger commands, debouncing works
    • Deps: [CF-TEST-005b]
    • Blocks: [CF-T21]

  • CF-T21 | P0 | Phase 6 | Est: 4h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Integration: Command → AI → Agent routing
    • Acceptance: Full flow: create task → embedding → suggest agent works
    • Deps: [CF-T20, CF-AI-006]
    • Blocks: [CF-T22]

  • CF-T22 | P0 | Phase 6 | Est: 4h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Integration: Multi-tenant data isolation
    • Acceptance: Different workspaces cannot access each other's data
    • Deps: [CF-T21]
    • Blocks: [CF-T23]

  • CF-T23 | P0 | Phase 6 | Est: 6h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: E2E: Complete user workflow simulation
    • Acceptance: Create→Update→Search→Close→Sync flow works end-to-end
    • Deps: [CF-T22]
    • Blocks: [CF-T24]

  • CF-T24 | P1 | Phase 6 | Est: 5h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: E2E: Multi-workspace collaboration
    • Acceptance: Two users syncing via git works, conflicts detected
    • Deps: [CF-T23]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-001]

Phase 7: Security & Performance Tests​

Goal: Security hardening and load testing Effort: 22h | Tasks: 5 | Agents: security-specialist, testing-specialist

Security Tests​

  • CF-T25 | P0 | Phase 7 | Est: 4h | Agent: security-specialist

    • Task: Input validation and injection prevention tests
    • Acceptance: SQL injection, command injection, XSS attempts fail safely
    • Deps: [CF-CLI-001]
    • Blocks: [CF-T26]

  • CF-T26 | P0 | Phase 7 | Est: 4h | Agent: security-specialist

    • Task: Authentication and authorization tests
    • Acceptance: Workspace isolation verified, unauthorized access blocked
    • Deps: [CF-T25, CF-DAEMON-003]
    • Blocks: [CF-T27]

Performance Tests​

  • CF-T27 | P1 | Phase 7 | Est: 5h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Load testing with 100+ concurrent operations
    • Acceptance: 100 concurrent creates complete in <10s, no data corruption
    • Deps: [CF-T26]
    • Blocks: [CF-T28]

  • CF-T28 | P1 | Phase 7 | Est: 4h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Database performance benchmarks
    • Acceptance: 10K tasks: list <1s, search <100ms, sync <5s
    • Deps: [CF-T27]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-001]

  • CF-T29 | P2 | Phase 7 | Est: 5h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Memory and CPU profiling
    • Acceptance: Daemon <50MB RAM idle, <200MB under load, no memory leaks
    • Deps: [CF-T28]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-004]

Phase 8: CI/CD Infrastructure (NEW - Per Quality Judge)​

Goal: Automated quality enforcement in pipeline Effort: 28h | Tasks: 8 | Agent: devops-engineer

CI Pipeline​

  • CF-T12 | P0 | Phase 8 | Est: 4h | Agent: devops-engineer

    • Task: GitHub Actions workflow for test suite
    • Acceptance: Tests run on PR, main branch; matrix: Linux, macOS, Windows
    • Deps: [CF-T01 through CF-T10]
    • Blocks: [CF-T13]

  • CF-T13 | P0 | Phase 8 | Est: 2h | Agent: devops-engineer

    • Task: Pre-commit hook configuration
    • Acceptance: cargo fmt, cargo clippy, cargo test --lib run before commit
    • Deps: [CF-T12]
    • Blocks: [CF-T14]

  • CF-T14 | P0 | Phase 8 | Est: 2h | Agent: devops-engineer

    • Task: Coverage reporting with Codecov/tarpaulin
    • Acceptance: Coverage badge in README, 95% minimum enforced
    • Deps: [CF-T12]
    • Blocks: [CF-T15]

  • CF-T15 | P0 | Phase 8 | Est: 4h | Agent: devops-engineer

    • Task: Quality gate enforcement in CI
    • Acceptance: PR blocked if: coverage <95%, clippy warnings, failing tests
    • Deps: [CF-T14]
    • Blocks: [CF-T16]

  • CF-T16 | P1 | Phase 8 | Est: 3h | Agent: devops-engineer

    • Task: Security scanning with Snyk/Dependabot
    • Acceptance: Dependency vulnerabilities detected, PR comments added
    • Deps: [CF-T15]
    • Blocks: [CF-T17]

  • CF-T17 | P1 | Phase 8 | Est: 4h | Agent: devops-engineer

    • Task: Performance benchmark CI with regression detection
    • Acceptance: Benchmarks run nightly, >10% regression fails build
    • Deps: [CF-T28]
    • Blocks: [CF-T18]

  • CF-T18 | P1 | Phase 8 | Est: 3h | Agent: devops-engineer

    • Task: Docker build and test CI
    • Acceptance: Multi-arch images built, pushed to ghcr.io/coditect/codiflow
    • Deps: [CF-T15]
    • Blocks: [CF-T19]

  • CF-T19 | P1 | Phase 8 | Est: 6h | Agent: devops-engineer

    • Task: Integration test environment with ephemeral workspaces
    • Acceptance: Tests run in isolated containers, clean state each run
    • Deps: [CF-T10, CF-T18]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-001]

Phase 9: Quality Gates (NEW - Per Quality Judge)​

Goal: Define objective completion criteria for each phase Effort: 8h | Tasks: 4 | Agent: testing-specialist

  • CF-GATE-001 | P0 | Phase 9 | Est: 2h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Phase 1-3 Quality Gate definition
    • Acceptance: Gate criteria documented: coverage ≥95%, no critical issues, benchmarks pass
    • Deps: [CF-T14]
    • Blocks: [CF-GATE-002]

  • CF-GATE-002 | P0 | Phase 9 | Est: 2h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Phase 4-6 Quality Gate definition
    • Acceptance: Integration test gates defined, sync validation criteria documented
    • Deps: [CF-GATE-001]
    • Blocks: [CF-GATE-003]

  • CF-GATE-003 | P0 | Phase 9 | Est: 2h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Phase 7-8 Quality Gate definition
    • Acceptance: Security and performance gate criteria documented
    • Deps: [CF-GATE-002]
    • Blocks: [CF-GATE-004]

  • CF-GATE-004 | P0 | Phase 9 | Est: 2h | Agent: testing-specialist

    • Task: Production readiness checklist
    • Acceptance: 50-item checklist covering all quality dimensions
    • Deps: [CF-GATE-003]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-001]

Phase 10: Polish & Documentation​

Goal: Production-ready release with documentation Effort: 24h | Tasks: 6 | Agents: rust-expert-developer, codi-documentation-writer, cli-tools-specialist

  • CF-POLISH-001 | P0 | Phase 10 | Est: 4h | Agent: codi-documentation-writer

    • Task: README with quick start and examples
    • Acceptance: README covers: install, init, create, list, search, sync
    • Deps: [CF-GATE-004, CF-T24]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-002]

  • CF-POLISH-002 | P1 | Phase 10 | Est: 4h | Agent: cli-tools-specialist

    • Task: Shell completions for bash, zsh, fish, PowerShell
    • Acceptance: Tab completion works for all commands and options
    • Deps: [CF-POLISH-001, CF-AI-005]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-003]

  • CF-POLISH-003 | P1 | Phase 10 | Est: 4h | Agent: codi-documentation-writer

    • Task: API documentation with examples
    • Acceptance: All public APIs documented with rustdoc, examples compile
    • Deps: [CF-POLISH-001, CF-SYNC-004]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-004]

  • CF-POLISH-004 | P1 | Phase 10 | Est: 4h | Agent: devops-engineer

    • Task: Cross-platform binary releases
    • Acceptance: Static binaries <10MB for: x86_64-linux, x86_64-darwin, aarch64-darwin, x86_64-windows
    • Deps: [CF-POLISH-003, CF-DAEMON-006, CF-T29]
    • Blocks: [CF-POLISH-005]

  • CF-POLISH-005 | P2 | Phase 10 | Est: 4h | Agent: codi-documentation-writer

    • Task: Migration guide from Beads to CodiFlow
    • Acceptance: Guide covers: data export, import, command mapping, feature parity
    • Deps: [CF-POLISH-004, CF-DAEMON-007]
    • Blocks: None

  • CF-POLISH-006 | P2 | Phase 10 | Est: 4h | Agent: codi-documentation-writer

    • Task: CODITECT integration guide
    • Acceptance: Guide covers: /cf commands, agent invocation, context.db integration
    • Deps: [CF-POLISH-005]
    • Blocks: None

Summary Statistics​

Task Counts​

CategoryOriginalAfter Judge Revisions
Core Implementation8787
TDD Test Tasks010
Integration/E2E Tests715
Security/Performance Tests05
CI/CD Infrastructure08
Quality Gates04
Total87115

Test Coverage​

MetricBeforeAfter
Test Tasks7 (8%)35 (30.4%)
TDD Compliance0%100%
Quality Gates04
CI/CD Tasks08

Effort Distribution​

PhaseTasksHoursAgents
Phase 0: TDD Foundation1030htesting-specialist, database-architect
Phase 1: Core Infrastructure1248hrust-expert-developer, database-architect
Phase 2: CLI Implementation936hrust-expert-developer
Phase 3: AI Intelligence1040hai-specialist, rust-expert-developer
Phase 4: Sync Engine836hrust-expert-developer, devops-engineer
Phase 5: Daemon Architecture732hrust-expert-developer, devops-engineer
Phase 6: Integration Tests840htesting-specialist
Phase 7: Security/Performance522hsecurity-specialist, testing-specialist
Phase 8: CI/CD Infrastructure828hdevops-engineer
Phase 9: Quality Gates48htesting-specialist
Phase 10: Polish & Documentation624hcodi-documentation-writer, cli-tools-specialist
Total87344h7 agent types

Timeline​

MilestoneDateDeliverable
TDD FoundationJan 6Test scaffolding complete
Core InfrastructureJan 20Storage + Business logic
CLI + AIFeb 10Full CLI with AI features
Sync + DaemonFeb 24Background sync operational
Testing CompleteMar 495% coverage achieved
Public LaunchMar 11CodiFlow Beta

Approval Status​

JudgeScoreStatus
Architecture Judge36/40APPROVED WITH MINOR REVISIONS
Quality Judge7/40 → 40/40APPROVED (after incorporating 28 test tasks)
Final40/40APPROVED FOR IMPLEMENTATION

Next Steps​

  1. Week 1 (Dec 23-29): Deploy Beads for Pilot Launch
  2. Week 2-3 (Dec 30 - Jan 10): Execute Phase 0 (TDD Foundation)
  3. Week 4-6 (Jan 11 - Feb 3): Execute Phases 1-3 (Core + CLI + AI)
  4. Week 7-9 (Feb 3 - Feb 24): Execute Phases 4-5 (Sync + Daemon)
  5. Week 10-12 (Feb 24 - Mar 11): Execute Phases 6-10 (Testing + Polish)
  6. March 11: CodiFlow Beta at Public Launch
  7. Month 6: Market-driven decision (Beads vs CodiFlow)

Document Status: FINAL Generated By: MoE Analysis Framework (5 Experts + 2 Judges) Date: December 22, 2025 Owner: Hal Casteel, Founder/CEO/CTO