Sprint 2 Validation & Sprint 3 Planning
Date: 2025-10-19 Status: Sprint 2 COMPLETE โ - Validation Required โ ๏ธ Next Phase: Sprint 3 - Frontend/Backend Integration & Real-World Validation
๐ฏ Executive Summaryโ
Current Stateโ
- Backend API (V5): โ Deployed and healthy (3/3 pods)
- Combined Frontend+theia: โ Deployed and healthy (3/3 pods)
- Production URLs: โ Configured and accessible
- Build Status: โ Latest build #19 deployed (Oct 19, 2025)
Critical Gapโ
END-TO-END USER VALIDATION NOT COMPLETED
While all infrastructure is deployed and healthy, we have NOT validated:
- โ User can access https://coditect.ai (200 OK)
- โ User can register new account via frontend
- โ User can login and get JWT token
- โ User can access theia IDE after login
- โ User can open terminal in theia
- โ User can perform real work (git, npm, file editing)
- โ Session persists across page reloads
๐ Deployment Status (Sprint 2 Complete)โ
Build Historyโ
| Build | ID | Status | Date | Deployment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #19 | 8860dda8 | โ SUCCESS | Oct 19 18:52 | PRODUCTION (Combined) |
| #18 | 3489e960 | โ SUCCESS | Oct 19 18:36 | PRODUCTION (Backend) |
| #17 | 2a767f2a | โ SUCCESS | Oct 19 13:11 | Superseded |
| #16 | 8b0cf3a1 | โ SUCCESS | Oct 19 12:41 | Superseded |
| #15 | fe1dde46 | โ SUCCESS | Oct 19 11:17 | Superseded |
| #14 | 60d0f652 | โ SUCCESS | Oct 19 09:43 | Superseded |
| #13 | 38c75204 | โ SUCCESS | Oct 19 08:48 | Superseded |
| #12 | 13e4134c | โ SUCCESS | Oct 19 06:50 | Superseded |
Currently Deployed Imagesโ
Backend API (coditect-api-v5):
- Image:
us-central1-docker.pkg.dev/serene-voltage-464305-n2/coditect/coditect-v5-api:3489e960-172c-4791-b228-e6dbf9cdab14 - Build: #18 (
3489e960) - Pods: 3/3 Running (119m old)
- Health: โ
/api/v5/healthreturns 200
Combined Frontend+theia (coditect-combined):
- Image:
us-central1-docker.pkg.dev/serene-voltage-464305-n2/coditect/coditect-combined:8860dda8-5443-469f-b690-36d904711d1c - Build: #19 (
8860dda8) - Pods: 3/3 Running (112m old)
- Health: โ Homepage loads at https://coditect.ai
FoundationDB:
- Pods: 3/3 StatefulSet + 2 proxy pods (all Running)
- Age: 4d15h
- Health: โ Connected to backend
Production URLs & Ingressโ
| URL | Backend | Status |
|---|---|---|
| https://coditect.ai | coditect-combined-service:80 | โ 200 OK |
| https://www.coditect.ai | coditect-combined-service:80 | โ Redirect |
| https://api.coditect.ai/api/v5 | coditect-api-v5-service:80 | โ 200 OK |
Ingress IP: 34.8.51.57
SSL: Google-managed certificate (active)
โ ๏ธ Validation Gaps Identifiedโ
1. Authentication Flow (CRITICAL)โ
Current State:
- โ
Login page exists at
/login(src/pages/login-page.tsx) - โ
Register page exists at
/register(src/pages/register-page.tsx) - โ Auth service implemented (src/services/auth-service.ts)
- โ ๏ธ Demo mode hardcoded (email: demo@coditect.ai, password: demo)
- โ Real backend authentication NOT TESTED
What Works:
// Demo login bypasses backend (auth-store.ts:89-113)
if (email === 'demo@coditect.ai' && password === 'demo') {
// Returns mock user, mock token
// Does NOT call backend API
}
What's Missing:
- No test of real registration flow (POST /api/v5/auth/register)
- No test of real login flow (POST /api/v5/auth/login)
- No verification JWT is stored correctly
- No test that JWT works with protected endpoints
2. Session Management (CRITICAL)โ
Current State:
- โ Session service exists (src/services/session-service.ts)
- โ Session store exists (src/stores/session-store.ts)
- โ Backend endpoints exist (POST /api/v5/sessions, GET /api/v5/sessions)
- โ Session creation NOT TESTED from frontend
- โ Session persistence to FoundationDB NOT VERIFIED
What's Missing:
- No test creating session after login
- No verification session saved to FDB
- No test listing user sessions
- No test deleting sessions
3. theia IDE Integration (CRITICAL)โ
Current State:
- โ theia container service exists (src/services/theia-container.ts)
- โ IDE layout component exists (src/components/layout.tsx)
- โ Route defined for /ide
- โ theia widgets NOT TESTED
- โ terminal access NOT VERIFIED
What's Missing:
- No test that /ide route loads theia iframe
- No verification theia terminal opens
- No test running commands in terminal (npm, git, ls)
- No verification file explorer works
- No test editing files in Monaco editor
4. End-to-End User Journey (CRITICAL)โ
Complete Flow NOT TESTED:
1. User navigates to https://coditect.ai
2. Clicks "Sign Up" โ /register
3. Fills form (email, password, firstName, lastName)
4. Submits โ POST /api/v5/auth/register
5. Receives JWT token + user object
6. Auto-redirects to /ide
7. theia IDE loads in iframe
8. User opens terminal
9. User runs: npm --version, git --version, ls -la
10. User creates file: touch test.md
11. User edits file in Monaco editor
12. User refreshes page โ Still logged in
13. User logs out โ Redirects to /login
Status: โ NONE OF THIS HAS BEEN VALIDATED
๐งช Detailed Validation Test Planโ
Phase 1: Infrastructure Validation (30 minutes)โ
Objective: Verify all services are healthy and accessible
Test 1.1: Frontend Accessibilityโ
# Test homepage loads
curl -s -o /dev/null -w "%{http_code}" https://coditect.ai
# Expected: 200
# Test page content
curl -s https://coditect.ai | grep -o '<title>.*</title>'
# Expected: <title>Coditect - AI-Powered IDE</title>
Test 1.2: Backend API Healthโ
# Test health endpoint
curl -s https://api.coditect.ai/api/v5/health
# Expected: {"success":true,"data":{"service":"coditect-v5-api","status":"healthy"}}
# Test ready endpoint
curl -s https://api.coditect.ai/api/v5/ready
# Expected: {"success":true,"data":{"status":"ready","fdb_connected":true}}
Test 1.3: FoundationDB Connectivityโ
# Check backend logs for FDB connection
kubectl logs -n coditect-app deployment/coditect-api-v5 --tail=20 | grep -i "fdb\|foundation"
# Expected: "FoundationDB connected successfully"
# Verify FDB pods
kubectl get pods -n coditect-app | grep foundationdb
# Expected: 3 Running pods
Expected Results: All tests pass โ
Phase 2: Authentication Flow Testing (1-2 hours)โ
Objective: Validate complete registration and login flows
Test 2.1: User Registration (Frontend โ Backend โ FDB)โ
Step 1: Access registration page
curl -s https://coditect.ai/register | grep -o '<title>.*</title>'
# Expected: Page loads
Step 2: Register new user via API
curl -X POST https://api.coditect.ai/api/v5/auth/register \
-H "Content-Type: application/json" \
-d '{
"email": "testuser@example.com",
"password": "SecurePass123!",
"firstName": "Test",
"lastName": "User"
}' | jq .
Expected Response:
{
"success": true,
"data": {
"token": "eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9...",
"user": {
"id": "uuid-here",
"tenantId": "uuid-here",
"email": "testuser@example.com",
"firstName": "Test",
"lastName": "User",
"role": "user",
"isActive": true,
"emailVerified": false,
"createdAt": "2025-10-19T...",
"updatedAt": "2025-10-19T..."
}
}
}
Step 3: Verify user in FoundationDB
# Connect to FDB pod
kubectl exec -it -n coditect-app foundationdb-0 -- fdbcli
# Inside fdbcli:
# getrange "" xFF
# Look for: /{tenant_id}/users/{user_id}
Step 4: Verify self-tenant created
# Inside fdbcli:
# Look for: /{tenant_id}/tenant
# Should contain: user_id link to registered user
Success Criteria:
- โ Registration returns 201 Created
- โ JWT token returned
- โ User object contains correct data
- โ User persisted in FDB under /{tenant_id}/users/{user_id}
- โ Self-tenant created atomically
Test 2.2: User Login (Frontend โ Backend โ JWT)โ
Step 1: Login via API
curl -X POST https://api.coditect.ai/api/v5/auth/login \
-H "Content-Type: application/json" \
-d '{
"email": "testuser@example.com",
"password": "SecurePass123!"
}' | jq .
Expected Response:
{
"success": true,
"data": {
"token": "eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9...",
"user": { ... }
}
}
Step 2: Verify AuthSession created
# Inside fdbcli:
# getrange /{tenant_id}/auth_sessions ""
# Should show: New AuthSession with is_active=true
Step 3: Test JWT validation
# Extract token from login response
TOKEN="eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9..."
# Test protected endpoint
curl -X GET https://api.coditect.ai/api/v5/users/me \
-H "Authorization: Bearer $TOKEN" | jq .
Expected Response:
{
"success": true,
"data": {
"id": "uuid-here",
"email": "testuser@example.com",
...
}
}
Success Criteria:
- โ Login returns 200 OK
- โ JWT token valid and not expired
- โ AuthSession created in FDB
- โ Protected endpoint accepts JWT
- โ User data retrieved correctly
Test 2.3: Frontend Integration (Browser Testing)โ
Manual Browser Test:
- Open https://coditect.ai/register
- Fill Form:
- Email:
newuser@example.com - Password:
SecurePass123! - Display Name:
New User
- Email:
- Submit form
- Verify:
- Redirects to /ide
- No errors in browser console
- LocalStorage contains:
auth-storagewith user + token
- Reload Page
- Verify:
- Still logged in (no redirect to /login)
- User data persists
- Logout
- Verify:
- Redirects to /login
- LocalStorage cleared
- Cannot access /ide (redirects to /login)
Success Criteria:
- โ Registration form works end-to-end
- โ Login persists across page reloads
- โ Logout invalidates session
Phase 3: Session Management Testing (1-2 hours)โ
Objective: Validate workspace session CRUD operations
Test 3.1: Create Sessionโ
# Login first to get token
TOKEN=$(curl -s -X POST https://api.coditect.ai/api/v5/auth/login \
-H "Content-Type: application/json" \
-d '{"email":"testuser@example.com","password":"SecurePass123!"}' | jq -r .data.token)
# Create workspace session
curl -X POST https://api.coditect.ai/api/v5/sessions \
-H "Authorization: Bearer $TOKEN" \
-H "Content-Type: application/json" \
-d '{
"name": "My First Session",
"activeFiles": [],
"metadata": {}
}' | jq .
Expected Response:
{
"success": true,
"data": {
"id": "uuid-here",
"tenantId": "tenant-uuid",
"userId": "user-uuid",
"name": "My First Session",
"activeFiles": [],
"metadata": {},
"createdAt": "2025-10-19T...",
"updatedAt": "2025-10-19T..."
}
}
Verify in FDB:
# Inside fdbcli:
# getrange /{tenant_id}/workspace_sessions ""
# Should show: New session persisted
Test 3.2: List Sessionsโ
curl -X GET https://api.coditect.ai/api/v5/sessions \
-H "Authorization: Bearer $TOKEN" | jq .
Expected: Array of sessions for authenticated user
Test 3.3: Get Session by IDโ
SESSION_ID="uuid-from-create"
curl -X GET https://api.coditect.ai/api/v5/sessions/$SESSION_ID \
-H "Authorization: Bearer $TOKEN" | jq .
Expected: Session object with correct data
Test 3.4: Delete Sessionโ
curl -X DELETE https://api.coditect.ai/api/v5/sessions/$SESSION_ID \
-H "Authorization: Bearer $TOKEN" | jq .
Expected: 204 No Content or 200 OK
Verify in FDB:
# Session should be removed from FDB
Success Criteria:
- โ Sessions created successfully
- โ Sessions persisted to FDB
- โ List returns only user's sessions
- โ Delete removes from FDB
- โ Tenant isolation works (cannot access other tenant's sessions)
Phase 4: theia IDE Integration Testing (2-4 hours)โ
Objective: Validate theia IDE loads and terminal works
Test 4.1: IDE Route Accessโ
Browser Test:
- Login at https://coditect.ai/login
- Navigate to https://coditect.ai/ide
- Verify:
- theia IDE loads in iframe
- No CORS errors in console
- Monaco editor visible
- File explorer visible
- terminal widget visible
Test 4.2: terminal Functionalityโ
Interactive Test:
- Open terminal in theia IDE
- Run commands:
pwd
ls -la
npm --version
node --version
git --version
echo "Hello Coditect" > test.txt
cat test.txt - Verify:
- All commands execute successfully
- Output displays correctly
- File created:
test.txt
Test 4.3: File Operationsโ
Interactive Test:
- Create file:
Right-click โ New File โ hello.js - Edit file in Monaco:
console.log("Hello from Coditect V5"); - Save file:
Ctrl+S - Run file in terminal:
node hello.js - Verify:
- File saved successfully
- Executes and prints output
Test 4.4: Session Persistence (Critical!)โ
Test Flow:
- Create session via frontend
- Open files in theia
- Make edits
- Refresh browser page
- Verify:
- Session restored
- Files still open
- Unsaved changes preserved (if implemented)
Success Criteria:
- โ theia IDE loads without errors
- โ terminal opens and executes commands
- โ File operations work (create, edit, save, delete)
- โ Monaco editor syntax highlighting works
- โ Session state persists across page reloads
Phase 5: End-to-End User Journey (2-3 hours)โ
Objective: Validate complete real-world workflow
Complete User Journey Testโ
Step 1: Registration
- Navigate: https://coditect.ai
- Click: "Sign Up"
- Fill: email=realuser@test.com, password=Test123!, name=Real User
- Submit
- Verify: Redirects to /ide
Step 2: IDE Access
- Verify: theia IDE loaded
- Verify: Welcome message displayed
- Verify: File explorer shows workspace
Step 3: terminal Work
- Open terminal
- Run:
mkdir my-project
cd my-project
npm init -y
echo "console.log('Hello');" > index.js
node index.js - Verify: All commands work, output correct
Step 4: Session Management
- Create new session: "Backend Work"
- Switch to new session
- Verify: Clean workspace (previous files not visible)
- Create file:
backend.js - Switch back to first session
- Verify: Original files visible, new file not visible
Step 5: Persistence Test
- Refresh browser
- Verify: Still logged in
- Verify: Session tabs restored
- Verify: File tree preserved
Step 6: Logout
- Click: "Logout"
- Verify: Redirects to /login
- Try accessing: https://coditect.ai/ide
- Verify: Redirects to /login (protected route)
Success Criteria:
- โ Complete flow works without errors
- โ Real work can be performed
- โ Multi-session isolation works
- โ Persistence across reloads works
- โ Authentication protects IDE route
๐จ Critical Blockers & Risksโ
Blocker 1: Demo Mode Prevents Real Testingโ
Issue: Auth store has hardcoded demo mode that bypasses backend
Location: src/stores/auth-store.ts:89-113
Impact: Cannot test real authentication flow while demo mode active
Solution: Add environment flag to disable demo mode in production
const DEMO_MODE = import.meta.env.VITE_DEMO_MODE === 'true'
if (DEMO_MODE && email === 'demo@coditect.ai' && password === 'demo') {
// Demo login
}
Priority: P0 - Must fix before validation
Blocker 2: API Base URL Configurationโ
Issue: Need to verify API_BASE_URL is correctly set to /api/v5
Location: src/services/api-client.ts
Current: Hardcoded to /api/v5 (correct for production)
Risk: If using localhost:8080 in any service, will fail in production
Validation Required:
# Check deployed bundle
curl -s https://coditect.ai/assets/*.js | grep -o 'localhost:8080'
# Expected: No matches
curl -s https://coditect.ai/assets/*.js | grep -o '/api/v5'
# Expected: Multiple matches
Priority: P0 - Must verify before validation
Blocker 3: theia Container URLโ
Issue: Need to verify theia iframe URL is correct
Location: src/services/theia-container.ts
Risk: If theia URL points to wrong service, IDE won't load
Validation Required: Browser inspection of iframe src attribute
Priority: P0 - Must verify before validation
Risk 1: CORS Configurationโ
Issue: Cross-origin requests may fail between frontend and theia
Mitigation: NGINX routing should handle this (same domain)
Validation: Check browser console for CORS errors
Priority: P1 - Monitor during testing
Risk 2: JWT Token Expirationโ
Issue: Access tokens expire after 15 minutes
Impact: User session interrupted if refresh fails
Validation Required: Test token refresh flow after 15 minutes
Priority: P1 - Not blocking initial validation
Risk 3: FoundationDB Transaction Limitsโ
Issue: FDB has 5-second transaction timeout
Impact: Large file operations may fail
Validation: Test uploading/editing large files
Priority: P2 - Not blocking initial validation
๐ฏ Sprint 3 Planโ
Sprint 3 Objectivesโ
Duration: 1-2 weeks Focus: Frontend/Backend Integration + Real-World Validation
Phase 1: Fix Demo Mode & Blockers (Day 1 - 4 hours)โ
Tasks:
- Add
VITE_DEMO_MODEenvironment flag - Update auth store to respect flag
- Verify API_BASE_URL in deployed bundle
- Verify theia container URL
- Fix any CORS issues discovered
- Deploy build with fixes
Deliverable: Production build with demo mode configurable
Phase 2: Authentication Integration (Days 2-3 - 8 hours)โ
Tasks:
- Execute Test 2.1: User Registration
- Execute Test 2.2: User Login
- Execute Test 2.3: Frontend Integration
- Fix any bugs discovered
- Verify JWT middleware works
- Verify AuthSession tracking
- Test token refresh flow
Deliverable: Working registration and login flows
Phase 3: Session Management Integration (Days 4-5 - 8 hours)โ
Tasks:
- Execute Test 3.1-3.4: Session CRUD
- Verify FDB persistence
- Test tenant isolation
- Implement session switching in UI
- Test multi-session workflows
Deliverable: Working session management
Phase 4: theia IDE Integration (Days 6-8 - 12 hours)โ
Tasks:
- Execute Test 4.1: IDE Route Access
- Execute Test 4.2: terminal Functionality
- Execute Test 4.3: File Operations
- Execute Test 4.4: Session Persistence
- Fix theia widget integration
- Verify Monaco editor works
- Test file explorer
- Test terminal commands
Deliverable: Fully functional theia IDE
Phase 5: End-to-End Validation (Days 9-10 - 8 hours)โ
Tasks:
- Execute Phase 5: Complete User Journey
- Perform load testing (100 concurrent users)
- Test edge cases and error scenarios
- Verify performance (< 200ms API responses)
- Document any limitations or known issues
Deliverable: Validated production deployment
Phase 6: LM Studio Integration (Days 11-14 - 16 hours)โ
Tasks:
- Integrate LM Studio MCP server
- Test 16+ model access
- Implement model selection UI
- Add chat interface
- Test multi-llm workflows
- Verify local-only processing
Deliverable: Multi-llm features working
๐ Sprint 3 Success Criteriaโ
Must Have (P0)โ
- โ User can register account
- โ User can login and receive JWT
- โ User can access theia IDE
- โ terminal works for real commands
- โ Files can be created and edited
- โ Sessions persist across page reloads
- โ Logout invalidates session
Should Have (P1)โ
- โ Multi-session workflows work
- โ Session switching UI implemented
- โ Token refresh prevents session interruption
- โ Error handling graceful
- โ Performance acceptable (< 200ms)
Nice to Have (P2)โ
- โ LM Studio integration complete
- โ 16+ models accessible
- โ Chat interface implemented
- โ Load testing shows scalability
- โ Documentation updated
๐ Next Session Action Itemsโ
Immediate (First 1 hour)โ
- Run Phase 1 validation (infrastructure tests)
- Check for demo mode blockers (verify VITE_DEMO_MODE)
- Verify API URLs (check deployed bundle)
- Test registration endpoint (curl test)
Short-term (Next 4 hours)โ
- Execute Phase 2 authentication tests
- Fix any discovered bugs
- Deploy fix build if needed
- Begin Phase 3 session tests
Medium-term (Next 2-3 days)โ
- Complete authentication integration
- Complete session management integration
- Begin theia IDE integration
- Document progress daily
๐ Related Documentationโ
- Latest Checkpoint:
docs/10-execution-plans/phased-deployment-checklist.md - Sprint 2 Session:
docs/09-sessions/2025-10=20-EXPORT-SPRINT-2.txt - Testing Strategy:
docs/testing/testing-strategy.md - Architecture:
docs/DEFINITIVE-V5-architecture.md - Backend Summary:
docs/06-backend/backend-summary.md
Last Updated: 2025-10-19T19:30:00Z Status: Sprint 2 COMPLETE - Ready for Validation Next Milestone: Sprint 3 - End-to-End Integration Testing