Skip to main content

ADR-016 QA Verification Checklist

Part 1 Requirements Check​

✅ Document Specification Block​

  • Present at top of document
  • All required fields (Document, Version, Purpose, Audience, Dates, Status)

✅ Required Sections Present​

  • 1. Document Information
  • 2. Purpose of this ADR (dual purpose stated)
  • 3. User Story Context with acceptance criteria
  • 4. Executive Summary (business & technical)
  • 5. Visual Overview (3 diagrams present)
  • 6. Background & Problem
  • 7. Decision with Y-Statement
  • 8. Consequences (positive & negative)
  • 9. References & Standards
  • 10. Review & Approval

✅ Visual Requirements​

  • Minimum 2 diagrams (has 3)
  • Business-friendly diagram ✓
  • Technical architecture ✓
  • Performance comparison ✓

✅ Missing from Part 1 (Should be in Part 2)​

  • Implementation Blueprint ✓ (correctly in Part 2)
  • Testing Strategy ✓ (correctly in Part 2)
  • Security Considerations ✓ (correctly in Part 2)
  • Performance Characteristics ✓ (correctly in Part 2)
  • Operational Considerations ✓ (correctly in Part 2)
  • Migration Strategy ✓ (correctly in Part 2)

Part 2 Requirements Check​

✅ Document Specification Block​

  • Present at top
  • Different document name suffix (-part2)

✅ Technical Sections Present​

  • 8. Implementation Blueprint
    • 8.1 Architecture Diagram
    • 8.2 Dependencies (complete cargo.toml)
    • 8.3 Core Implementation (main.rs)
    • 8.4 API Specification (log command)
    • 8.5 Data Models
    • 8.6 Configuration
    • 8.7 Logging Requirements ✓ (CRITICAL v4.1)
    • 8.8 Error Handling ✓ (CRITICAL v4.1)
  • 9. Testing Strategy
    • 9.1 Unit Tests
    • 9.2 Integration Tests
    • 9.3 Test Coverage Requirements ✓ (CRITICAL v4.1)
  • 10. Security Considerations
  • 11. Performance Characteristics
  • 12. Operational Considerations
  • 13. Migration Strategy

✅ Code Quality​

  • Dependencies with exact versions
  • Code compiles (Rust syntax valid)
  • Complete implementations (not snippets)
  • File paths indicated

✅ Test Coverage Requirements (Section 9.3)​

  • Unit Test Coverage: ≥ 90% ✓
  • Integration Test Coverage: ≥ 80% ✓
  • Critical Path Coverage: 100% ✓
  • Error Path Coverage: 100% ✓

Cross-Document Consistency​

✅ Linking​

  • Part 1 references Part 2 ✓
  • Part 1 references QA Review ✓
  • Both parts reference related ADR-009 ✓

✅ Back-to-Top Links​

  • Part 1 has back-to-top link at end ✓
  • Part 2 has back-to-top link at end ✓

CRITICAL v4.1 Requirements​

✅ Logging Pattern (Section 8.7)​

  • Standard logging format shown
  • Log levels defined
  • Component-based logging
  • Tracing integration

✅ Error Handling (Section 8.8)​

  • Error type definitions
  • User-friendly messages
  • Recovery suggestions
  • Proper error propagation

✅ Test Requirements​

  • Unit tests example
  • Integration tests example
  • Coverage percentages specified
  • Test-first mentioned

Final Verification​

Part 1 Score: 40/40 (100%)​

  • All required sections present
  • Excellent dual-audience content
  • Strong visual elements
  • Clear decision rationale

Part 2 Score: 40/40 (100%)​

  • Complete technical implementation
  • All v4.1 requirements met
  • Runnable code examples
  • Comprehensive test strategy

CONCLUSION: BOTH DOCUMENTS PASS QA REVIEW ✅​

No rework needed. Ready to proceed with implementation.