Skip to main content

ADR-028 QA Review Assignment

Assignment Details​

Document: ADR-028-v4-codi2-separation-of-concerns
Assigned To: CODI-QA-AGENT-21
Assignment Date: 2025-09-06
Status: PENDING_REVIEW
Priority: HIGH

Documents to Review​

  1. Part 1 - Narrative: adr-028-v4-codi2-separation-of-concerns-part1-narrative.md

    • Focus on human understanding and clarity
    • Check visual diagrams and user stories
    • Verify business value communication

  2. Part 2 - Technical: adr-028-v4-codi2-separation-of-concerns-part2-technical.md

    • Validate technical completeness
    • Check code examples compile
    • Verify implementation is unambiguous

Review Requirements​

Use QA Review Guide v4.2​

  • Score each part independently (40 points each)
  • Each part must achieve 100% (40/40) to pass
  • Use structured scoring rubric

Key Focus Areas​

  1. Separation of Concerns: Verify clear distinction between logging, messaging, and state
  2. Race Condition Prevention: Ensure design eliminates all identified race conditions
  3. Migration Path: Check feasibility of migration from CODI v1 to CODI2
  4. Performance Claims: Validate 10-100x improvement claims

Deliverable​

Create ADR-028-v4-codi2-separation-of-concerns-QA-REVIEW.md with:

  • Independent scoring for Part 1 and Part 2
  • Specific feedback on any issues
  • Clear pass/fail recommendation
  • Required improvements if any

Context​

This ADR represents a fundamental redesign of CODI based on first principles analysis showing that the current system conflates logging with messaging and state management, causing race conditions and performance issues.

Timeline​

Please complete review within standard QA cycle timeframe.

Assignment logged in CODI system at 2025-09-06