Skip to main content

ADR-028 QA Re-Review Assignment

Assignment Details​

Document: ADR-028-v4-codi2-separation-of-concerns
Assigned To: CODI-QA-AGENT-21
Assignment Date: 2025-09-06
Review Type: SECOND_REVIEW
Status: PENDING_RE_REVIEW
Priority: HIGH

Documents to Review (Now 3 Parts)​

  1. Part 1 - Narrative: adr-028-v4-codi2-separation-of-concerns-part1-narrative.md

    • Version 2.0.0
    • Updated with baseline metrics and 100% test coverage requirements
    • Added signature blocks and navigation

  2. Part 2 - Technical: adr-028-v4-codi2-separation-of-concerns-part2-technical.md

    • Version 2.0.0
    • Added 2 architecture diagrams (System Component & Data Flow)
    • Comprehensive error handling following ERROR-HANDLING-STANDARD-v4
    • Logging implementation following LOGGING-STANDARD-v4
    • Added monitoring, security, deployment sections

  3. Part 3 - Testing (NEW): adr-028-v4-codi2-separation-of-concerns-part3-testing.md

    • Version 1.0.0
    • 100% unit test coverage requirement
    • 100% integration test coverage requirement
    • Race condition tests, chaos engineering, performance tests
    • Complete test execution strategy

Issues Addressed from First Review​

Part 1 Issues (All Resolved)​

  • ✅ Added baseline comparison values for metrics
  • ✅ Added signature blocks
  • ✅ Added back-to-top navigation links
  • ✅ Updated test coverage to 100%/100%

Part 2 Issues (All Resolved)​

  • ✅ Added 2 technical architecture diagrams
  • ✅ Implemented comprehensive error handling
  • ✅ Updated logging to follow CODITECT standards
  • ✅ Added test coverage requirements (now 100%)
  • ✅ Added monitoring integration section
  • ✅ Added security considerations
  • ✅ Added deployment configuration
  • ✅ Added performance benchmarks

NEW: Part 3 Additions​

  • Comprehensive unit test examples
  • End-to-end integration tests
  • Critical path test coverage
  • Race condition elimination tests
  • Chaos engineering framework
  • Performance validation tests
  • CI/CD pipeline configuration

Key Changes Since Last Review​

  1. Test Coverage Raised to 100%: Both unit and integration tests now require 100% coverage with zero-tolerance policy
  2. Part 3 Created: Entire document dedicated to testing strategy
  3. Inter-Agent Protocol: Fully specified message format, delivery guarantees, and routing patterns
  4. Standards Compliance: Full adherence to LOGGING-STANDARD-v4 and ERROR-HANDLING-STANDARD-v4

Expected Outcome​

All three parts should now achieve 40/40 (100%) scores according to ADR-QA-REVIEW-GUIDE-v4.2.

Re-review assignment logged in CODI system at 2025-09-06