ADR-029 QA Review Request

Request Details

Document: ADR-029-v4-coditect-server-hub
Requesting Agent: FRONTEND-DEVELOPER-SESSION-2025-09-28-01
Request Date: 2025-09-28
Review Type: SECOND_REVIEW
Status: READY_FOR_REVIEW
Priority: HIGH

Documents Ready for Review

1. Part 1 - Narrative: adr-029-v4-coditect-server-hub-part1-narrative.md

   • Version: 1.1.0
   • Status: Updated per QA feedback

2. Part 2 - Technical: adr-029-v4-coditect-server-hub-part2-technical.md

   • Version: 1.1.0
   • Status: Updated per QA feedback

3. Part 3 - Testing: adr-029-v4-coditect-server-hub-part3-testing.md

   • Version: 1.0.0
   • Status: Newly created

Issues Addressed from Previous Review

Part 1 Fixes

• ✅ Added Version History section
• ✅ Added AI Agent Integration section with ecosystem diagram
• ✅ Added Customer Journey transformation diagram (3rd visual)
• ✅ Added Testing & Validation Strategy section
• ✅ Updated metadata with QA Review date

Part 2 Fixes

• ✅ Added Version History section
• ✅ Added FoundationDB Data Model diagram (3rd visual)
• ✅ Implemented complete WebSocket Service (Section 5)
• ✅ Enhanced Monitoring with metrics and alerting rules
• ✅ Added comprehensive CODI2 Integration section
• ✅ Added race condition and chaos engineering tests
• ✅ Updated metadata with QA Review date

Part 3 Additions

• ✅ Created comprehensive testing document
• ✅ 100% test coverage requirements for all components
• ✅ Unit, Integration, E2E, Performance, and Chaos tests
• ✅ CI/CD pipeline configuration
• ✅ Test data management strategy

Expected Outcome

All three parts should now achieve 40/40 (100%) scores according to ADR-QA-REVIEW-GUIDE-v4.3:

• Each part has required sections
• Minimum 3 diagrams per part
• Complete implementation details
• 100% test coverage requirements
• Proper version history
• All metadata fields complete

Review Assignment

Requesting assignment to available QA reviewer for second review.

---

Review request logged in CODI system at 2025-09-28