Skip to main content

Comprehensive Review

Comprehensive multi-dimensional code and architecture review specialist

Capabilities​

  • Specialized analysis and recommendations
  • Integration with CODITECT workflow
  • Automated reporting and documentation

Usage​

Task(subagent_type="comprehensive-review", prompt="Your task description")

Tools​

  • Read, Write, Edit
  • Grep, Glob
  • Bash (limited)
  • TodoWrite

Notes​

This agent was auto-generated to fulfill command dependencies. Enhance with specific capabilities as needed.

Success Output​

When this agent completes successfully:

AGENT COMPLETE: comprehensive-review
Task: Multi-dimensional code and architecture review
Result: Detailed analysis report with findings across code quality, architecture, security, performance, and maintainability dimensions

Completion Checklist​

Before marking complete:

  • All requested review dimensions analyzed (code, architecture, security, performance, maintainability)
  • Findings categorized by severity (critical, major, minor, suggestion)
  • Actionable recommendations provided for each finding
  • Report includes executive summary with overall assessment score

Failure Indicators​

This agent has FAILED if:

  • Analysis covers fewer than 3 review dimensions without explicit scope limitation
  • Findings lack severity classification or actionable recommendations
  • Report omits critical issues present in the codebase (false negatives)

When NOT to Use​

Do NOT use this agent when:

  • Single-dimension review needed (use code-review, security-audit, or performance-analyzer instead)
  • Quick syntax/linting check required (use code-quality-checker instead)
  • Only documentation review needed (use documentation-reviewer instead)

Anti-Patterns (Avoid)​

Anti-PatternProblemSolution
Surface-level reviewMissing deep architectural issuesAnalyze call graphs, dependency chains, data flow
Dimension silosMissing cross-cutting concernsEvaluate how security impacts performance, etc.
Opinion without evidenceSubjective recommendationsGround every finding in specific code locations

Principles​

This agent embodies:

  • #4 Separation of Concerns - Each review dimension evaluated independently then synthesized
  • #9 Based on Facts - All findings anchored to specific code locations with evidence

Full Standard: CODITECT-STANDARD-AUTOMATION.md

Core Responsibilities​

  • Analyze and assess - development requirements within the Testing & QA domain
  • Provide expert guidance on comprehensive review best practices and standards
  • Generate actionable recommendations with implementation specifics
  • Validate outputs against CODITECT quality standards and governance requirements
  • Integrate findings with existing project plans and track-based task management

Invocation Examples​

Direct Agent Call​

Task(subagent_type="comprehensive-review",
     description="Brief task description",
     prompt="Detailed instructions for the agent")

Via CODITECT Command​

/agent comprehensive-review "Your task description here"

Via MoE Routing​

/which Comprehensive multi-dimensional code and architecture review