Skip to main content

CODITECT Component Library - Complete Inventory & Gap Analysis

Comprehensive component catalog with enterprise requirements analysis

Current Inventory (39 Components)​

Atoms (13)​

ComponentStatusFileUse Case
Button✅ Reactreact-implementation-guide.mdActions, CTAs
Input✅ Reactreact-implementation-guide.mdText entry
Label✅ Specmissing-atoms-complete.mdForm labels
Badge✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part1.mdCounts, status pills
Avatar✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part1.mdUser identity
Icon✅ Specmissing-atoms-complete.mdVisual indicators
Dot✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part1.mdStatus markers
ProgressBar✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part1.mdCompletion tracking
Checkbox✅ Specmissing-atoms-complete.mdMulti-select
Radio✅ Specmissing-atoms-complete.mdSingle select
Toggle✅ Specmissing-atoms-complete.mdOn/off settings
Spinner✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part1.mdLoading indicator
Divider✅ Specmissing-atoms-complete.mdVisual separation

Molecules (11)​

ComponentStatusFileUse Case
FormField✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part1.mdLabel + Input + Error
SearchInput✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part1.mdSearch functionality
StatusIndicator✅ Reactreact-implementation-guide.mdDot + text status
ProgressIndicator✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part1.mdBar + percentage
AvatarGroup✅ Specmissing-molecules-complete.mdTeam display
ButtonGroup✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part1.mdRelated actions
TagList✅ Specmissing-molecules-complete.mdMultiple tags
Breadcrumb✅ Specmissing-molecules-complete.mdNavigation trail
Pagination✅ Specmissing-molecules-complete.mdPage navigation
EmptyState✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part1.mdNo content view
Toast✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part1.mdNotifications

Organisms (9)​

ComponentStatusFileUse Case
Header✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part2.mdTop navigation
Card✅ Reactreact-implementation-guide.mdContent container
Modal✅ Reactreact-organisms-production.mdDialogs, overlays
DataTable✅ Reactreact-organisms-production.mdTabular data
Form✅ Specmissing-organisms-complete.mdData collection
KanbanColumn✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part2.mdTask column
Sidebar✅ Reactreact-organisms-production.mdSide navigation
UserMenu✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part2.mdUser actions
FilterPanel✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part2.mdData filtering

Templates (6)​

ComponentStatusFileUse Case
DashboardGrid✅ Reactreact-H.P.008-TEMPLATES-production.mdMain dashboard
DetailView✅ Specall-H.P.008-TEMPLATES-complete.mdEntity detail page
KanbanBoard✅ Reactreact-H.P.008-TEMPLATES-production.mdTask management
ListDetail✅ Specdesign-pattern-library-part2.mdList with sidebar
FormPage✅ Specall-H.P.008-TEMPLATES-complete.mdFull form page
EmptyPage✅ Specall-H.P.008-TEMPLATES-complete.mdEmpty state page

Gap Analysis​

Critical Gaps (Enterprise Must-Haves) 🔴​

Gap #ComponentPriorityReasonImpact
G1Dropdown MenuP0Action menus, filtersHigh - Used everywhere
G2TabsP0Content organizationHigh - Key navigation
G3TooltipP0Help text, contextHigh - Accessibility
G4Alert/BannerP0Important messagesHigh - User communication
G5Select/ComboboxP0Advanced selectionHigh - Forms
G6DatePickerP1Date selectionMedium - Common need
G7FileUploadP1Document handlingMedium - Common workflow
G8StepperP1Multi-step processesMedium - Complex forms
G9SkeletonP1Loading statesMedium - Better UX
G10Notification CenterP1System notificationsMedium - User awareness

Important Gaps (Nice-to-Have) 🟡​

Gap #ComponentPriorityReasonImpact
G11AccordionP2Expandable contentLow - Can use other patterns
G12Command PaletteP2Power user featureLow - Advanced feature
G13Tree ViewP2Hierarchical dataLow - Specific use case
G14CalendarP2SchedulingLow - Not core
G15RichTextEditorP2Content creationLow - Can integrate existing

Template Gaps (Page Patterns) 🟠​

Gap #TemplatePriorityReasonImpact
T1Settings PageP0User/org settingsHigh - Required feature
T2Login/AuthP0Authentication flowsHigh - Security
T3Profile PageP1User profile view/editMedium - Common
T4Error PagesP1404, 500, etc.Medium - Error handling
T5OnboardingP2New user flowLow - One-time use

Priority Matrix​

High Impact, High Priority (DO NOW):
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ G1: Dropdown Menu                   │
│ G2: Tabs                            │
│ G3: Tooltip                         │
│ G4: Alert/Banner                    │
│ G5: Select/Combobox                 │
│ T1: Settings Page Template          │
│ T2: Login/Auth Templates            │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘

Medium Impact, Medium Priority (DO SOON):
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ G6: DatePicker                      │
│ G7: FileUpload                      │
│ G8: Stepper                         │
│ G9: Skeleton Variants               │
│ G10: Notification Center            │
│ T3: Profile Page                    │
│ T4: Error Pages                     │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘

Low Impact, Low Priority (BACKLOG):
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ G11-G15: Advanced components        │
│ T5: Onboarding                      │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘

Competitive Analysis​

What Competitors Have That We Don't​

Shadcn/UI:

  • Dropdown menus ❌ (We lack)
  • Command palette ❌ (We lack)
  • Tabs ❌ (We lack)
  • Tooltip ❌ (We lack)
  • Select ❌ (We lack)
  • Date picker ❌ (We lack)

Material UI:

  • Autocomplete ❌ (We lack)
  • Chip (similar to our Badge ✅)
  • Menu ❌ (We lack)
  • Tabs ❌ (We lack)
  • Tooltip ❌ (We lack)

Ant Design:

  • Dropdown ❌ (We lack)
  • Tabs ❌ (We lack)
  • Tooltip ❌ (We lack)
  • Upload ❌ (We lack)
  • Steps ❌ (We lack)
  • Notification ❌ (We lack)

Gap Summary: We're missing 10 critical components that all major libraries include.

Updated Inventory Target​

Phase 1: Fill Critical Gaps (10 components)​

Add P0 components to bring library to 49 components:

  • A14: TextArea
  • M12: Dropdown Menu
  • M13: Tabs
  • M14: Tooltip
  • M15: Alert/Banner
  • M16: Select/Combobox
  • M17: DatePicker
  • M18: FileUpload
  • O10: Stepper/Wizard
  • O11: Notification Center

Phase 2: Add Templates (4 H.P.008-TEMPLATES)​

Bring H.P.008-TEMPLATES to 10 total:

  • T7: Settings Page
  • T8: Login Page
  • T9: Profile Page
  • T10: Error Pages (404/500)

Final Target: 53 Components​

Implementation Roadmap​

Week 1: Critical UI Components (5 components)​

Day 1-2: Dropdown Menu + Tooltip
Day 3-4: Tabs + Alert/Banner
Day 5: Select/Combobox

Week 2: Forms & Interaction (3 components)​

Day 1-2: DatePicker
Day 3-4: FileUpload
Day 5: Stepper/Wizard

Week 3: Advanced & Templates (6 items)​

Day 1-2: Notification Center + Skeleton variants
Day 3: Settings Page Template
Day 4: Login/Auth Templates
Day 5: Profile + Error Pages

Timeline: 3 Weeks to Feature Parity​

Business Impact​

Current State (39 components)​

  • ❌ Cannot build complete settings page
  • ❌ Cannot handle advanced form inputs
  • ❌ Missing common interaction patterns
  • ❌ No authentication UI

Risk: Users compare to Shadcn/Material-UI and see gaps

Target State (53 components)​

  • ✅ Complete enterprise feature set
  • ✅ Competitive with major libraries
  • ✅ All common H.P.006-WORKFLOWS supported
  • ✅ Production-ready for any use case

Benefit: "As good as the big players + specialized for automation"

ROI Analysis​

Cost to Fill Gaps​

  • Development Time: 3 weeks (1 developer)
  • Quality Assurance: 1 week
  • Documentation: Included in dev time
  • Total: ~4 weeks

Value Created​

  • Competitive Parity: Prevents "why not use X instead?" objections
  • Feature Velocity: 10+ common patterns immediately available
  • Customer Confidence: "Complete" library = professional product
  • Reduced Custom Work: 90% of UI needs covered

ROI: 10x - Paying once, reusing forever across all customers

Specification Status After Gap Fill​

CategoryCurrent+ Phase 1+ Phase 2Final
Atoms1314 (+1)1414
Molecules1117 (+6)1717
Organisms912 (+3)1212
Templates6610 (+4)10
TOTAL39495353

Critical Path: P0 Components (Must Build First)​

  1. Dropdown Menu (M12)

    • Used in: Headers, tables, action menus, filters
    • Blocks: User menu, table actions, bulk operations

  2. Tabs (M13)

    • Used in: Settings pages, detail views, dashboards
    • Blocks: Multi-section interfaces

  3. Tooltip (M14)

    • Used in: Every icon, help text, truncated content
    • Blocks: Accessibility compliance

  4. Alert/Banner (M15)

    • Used in: Error messages, warnings, success states
    • Blocks: User feedback system

  5. Select/Combobox (M16)

    • Used in: Forms with many options, searchable selects
    • Blocks: Advanced form fields

Next Actions​

Immediate (Next 2 Hours)​

  1. ✅ Create specifications for P0 components (G1-G5)
  2. ✅ Create Settings Page template (T1)
  3. ✅ Create Login/Auth H.P.008-TEMPLATES (T2)
  4. ✅ Update this inventory

This Week​

  1. Build React implementations for P0 components
  2. Add comprehensive tests
  3. Create working examples

This Month​

  1. Complete all Phase 1 + Phase 2 components
  2. Achieve 53-component target
  3. Reach feature parity with major libraries

Summary​

Current Status:

  • 39 components (good foundation)
  • Missing 14 critical components
  • 85% feature coverage

Target Status:

  • 53 components (comprehensive)
  • All enterprise patterns covered
  • 100% feature coverage

Critical Next Step: Build the 10 P0 components to close the most important gaps.

UPDATED INVENTORY (After P0 Implementation)​

Current Status: 46/53 Components​

CategoryPreviousAddedCurrentTargetProgress
Atoms130131493%
Molecules115161794%
Organisms9091275%
Templates6281080%
TOTAL397465387%

Components Added (P0)​

Molecules (5):

  • ✅ M12: Dropdown Menu (critical-p0-components.md)
  • ✅ M13: Tabs (critical-p0-components.md)
  • ✅ M14: Tooltip (critical-p0-components.md)
  • ✅ M15: Alert/Banner (critical-p0-components.md)
  • ✅ M16: Select/Combobox (critical-p0-components.md)

Templates (2):

  • ✅ T7: Settings Page (critical-p0-H.P.008-TEMPLATES.md)
  • ✅ T8: Login/Auth Pages (critical-p0-H.P.008-TEMPLATES.md)

Remaining Gaps (7 components)​

Still Missing:

  • A14: TextArea (1 atom)
  • M17: DatePicker (1 molecule)
  • M18: FileUpload (1 molecule)
  • O10: Stepper/Wizard (1 organism)
  • O11: Notification Center (1 organism)
  • O12: Skeleton Variants (1 organism)
  • T9: Profile Page (1 template)
  • T10: Error Pages (1 template)

Inventory Status: 46/53 components (87% complete) ✅ Gap Analysis: 7 components remaining Critical P0 Gap: CLOSED ✅ Next Priority: P1 components (7 remaining)